SPE 521: Article Review Assignment â€“ Overview
While the peer-review process is rigorous, articles still get published that may have claims that are too far reaching without sufficient data support. Thus, it is essential to be a critical consumer of research, and be able to take away the key messages of the paper and apply these findings to your current context. The purpose of this assignment is to expand your knowledge of autism research by critically evaluating two supplemental reading research journal articles that fit most closely with your own interests.
Write two concise, double-spaced,1-2 page article analyses each summarizing and reviewing critical components of a peer-reviewed journal article.
Select one of the following articles for each article review assignment. Links to the articles are provided in our online course site (Main Menu > Major Assignments > Article Review Assignment). Thoroughly review the article review assignment description and remember to attach a blank scoring grid to your assignment.Â You do NOT need to provide a copy of the article, but you DO need to reference it at the end.
Article 1:Rieth, S., Stahmer, A., Suhreinrich, J., Schreibman, L., Kennedy, J., & Ross, B. (2014). Identifying critical elements of treatment: Examining the use of turn taking in autism intervention. Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities, 29(3), 168-179.
Article 2:Odom, S., Collet-Klingenberg, L., Rogers, S., & Hatton, D. (2010). Evidence-based practices in interventions for children and youth with autism spectrum disorders. Preventing School Failure, 54(4), 275-282.
Article 3:Self, T., Scudder, R., Webeba, G., & Crumrine, D. (2007). A virtual approach to teaching safety skills to children with autism spectrum disorders. Topics in Language Disorders, 27(3), 242-253.
Article 4:Orsmond, G., Krauss, M., Seltzer, M., (2004). Peer Relationships and Social and Recreational Activities among Adolescents and Adults with Autism.Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 34(3), 245-256.
Article 5: Wong, C. (2013). A Play and Joint Attention Intervention for Teachers of Young Children with Autism: A Randomized Controlled Pilot Study. Autism: The International Journal of Research and Practice, 17(3),Â 340-357.
Perform the following tasks. (See scoring grid for a breakdown of requirements):
- Proper citation (3 points)
- Use APA format for citation of the article and any additional references in the body of the document and in a references section at the end of the paper.
- Summary (15 points)
- Write a brief summary (1-2 paragraphs) highlighting key concepts in the article. Please be sure to summarize the study using your own words, and not simply answer these questions pulling words from the way that the authors described it. Do not use any direct quotes from the text of the article. The summary should give the big picture of the article, not the fine details.
- Research question (2 points):
- What was the intent of the study?
- Population: (2 points)
- Who were the participants?
- What was the setting?
- Research Design: (3 points)
- Was this a primary or secondary research study?
- If a primary study, was it experimental or observational?
- Describe the specific design (e.g. randomized control trial, cohort study, case control study, systematic review, single-subject, etc.)
- Results: (2 points)
- What were the main results of the study?
- Reliability and Validity: (2 points)
- Did this study measure what it set out to measures?
- Are the results reproducable (consistent with other studies)?
- Conclusion:Â (4 points)
- What did the authors conclude?
- Did this study add to the literature?
- Where could this topic be further developed for future research?
- Quality analysis (6 points). In this brief section you will analyze the quality of the study and information provided.
- Describe the strengths of the article (3 points)
- What were some strengths of this study that you saw beyond what the authors said? What was new or interesting about the study?
- Â Describe limitations of the article (3 points)
- What were some limitations that you saw beyond what the authors said? What could have been done better? Was there any component that was too difficult or unlikely to be implemented in the natural environment?
Save and submit your Article Review Paper.
When you have completed the assignment, save a copy for yourself in an easily accessible place and submit a copy to your instructor using the lesson assignment link in Blackboard. Make sure you also upload a copy to your digication ePortfolio. Please include a copy of the Article Review Paper Scoring Grid with each paper in order to receive feedback. The instructor will comment and provide your score via the Gradebook area for your first article review prior to the due date for the second Article ReviewPaper.
Due dates and expected reading assignments are specified in the Course Schedule. The due date listed for each lesson Article Review Paper is the last day to submit the assignment for full credit. Article Review Papers can be completed as soon as desired (in advance of the due date), but papers received after the due date will be considered late and lose points for each day they are late.
Article Review Paper Scoring Grid
A total of 24 points can be earned for each assignment. Points will be assigned for accurate and complete information addressing each question/topic outlined in the activity details and summarized in the scoring grid. Failure to address a question/topic will result in lost points.
Article Review Scoring Grid
|Requirements||Points earned on Article Review 1||Points earned on Article Review 2||Points Possible on each assignment (total for both assignments)
|Citation in APA format||3 (6)|
|Research question||2 (4)|
|Research Design||3 (6)|
|Reliability and Validity||2 (4)|
|Individual Article Review Points||Â||Â||24 (48)|
Article Review Paper FAQs
- What exactly does a â€œbrief Article Review Paperâ€ mean?
A brief Article Review Paper is a 2-page (maximum) summary highlighting and analyzing key points from the article. Reference page will not be considered in the page count.
- When are my Article Review papers due?
Each AR Paper is due on the dates specified in the course schedule. The due date is the last day to submit an AR for full credit. ARPapers can be submitted early, but not past the due date.
- Will my grade also include mechanics?Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
As a graduate student, the quality of your mechanics is expected to be excellent. While an occasional typo or grammatical error will be overlooked, chronic mechanical errors will reduce your overall points.
- Do I need a reference list?
Yes, any time you are using anotherâ€™s materials, you must reference the source. For an excellent source for using APA format, please go to the APA style site: http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/01/.